ENGADGET

Microsoft' s getting quite aggressive with the price drops lately. Anybody have Blu-Ray vs. HD-DVD sales numbers?

Blu-Ray is either 2 to 1 or 3 to 1 over HD-DVD. A large portion of the Blu-Ray players are PS3s from what I' ve read. The HD-DVD price drops might see the tables turn though. Either way both are failing horribly at this point.

Its been $120, Eddie...

HDDVD is only around because MS is throwing around $$$ to prolong the format battle until they have their digital distribution perfected and ready.

ORIGINAL: immortaldanmx

Its been $120, Eddie...

HDDVD is only around because MS is throwing around $$$ to prolong the format battle until they have their digital distribution perfected and ready.

Your falling for that Michael Bay argument?! Hahaha!

And no, it hasn' t been $120. It' s been $179 with 5 free movies.

Your falling for that Michael Bay argument?! Hahaha!

And no, it hasn' t been $120. It' s been $179 with 5 free movies.

Yeah that Michale bay crap is bull shit like no other . Ms must think every body wonts to pay for download. That one dumb plan What happens if I wont to take my movie over my friends house . I guess I would have to Re-Download it or his hous huh.

Its just a dumb move.

Ahh, you were right on the price, I am becoming anhero now.

Ive rethought it and Rampage, youre right, Bay is wrong. MS is doing it as a last ditch effort to deliver a critical blow to Sony.

Blu-ray is killing HD-DVD. They' re already winning with a price disadvantage. Why would anyone invest HD-DVD? The difference is only going to grow as Blu-ray gets cheaper and the technology catches up to their potential. Once Rom drives reach sub 100$ mark and the Speed reaches their maximum for both formats. We' ll be looking at Bluray=18x or 648Mbps, HD-DVD=9x or 328.95Mbps as the maximum transfer speed for both formats (by my calculations). No one will want a HD-DVD rom drive in their PC once that happens. Especially when BD will have vastly more capacity per disc.

HD-DVD doesn' t have a very long future, Blu-ray does.

They' re already winning with a price disadvantage.

I believe you, and I support Blu-Ray, but where are you getting your source?

If MS wanted HD-DVD to win they should have built it into the 360 . I dont think it has a chance now .

If MS wanted HD-DVD to win they should have built it into the 360 . I dont think it has a chance now .

I dont think that would have helped them. In fact, it probably would have hurt them. They would have had to up the price(probably to around the same as the PS3) and then all the defective consoles probably wouldn' t have blown over well either.

I believe you, and I support Blu-Ray, but where are you getting your source?

I read tons of articles on tech news but it' s difficlut to find total sales numbers in one place. Every article I do read seem to favor Blu-ray though.

Neilson videoscan is something I trust. It seems to back up a lot of what I' ve read. I' m still looking for a graph with week by week sales since inception.

http://www.engadgethd.com/tag/VideoScan/

I support DVD which is kicking both their asses.

If I owned Blu-Ray and was waiting for Transformers, I' d be pissed.

So what do you do?

DVD of course!

I support DVD which is kicking both their asses.

If I owned Blu-Ray and was waiting for Transformers, I' d be pissed.

So what do you do?

DVD of course!

So true dvd is kicking ass but its on its last leg.

ORIGINAL: mikayd2

So true dvd is kicking ass but its on its last leg.

Since when was DVD on it' s last legs?

Last I hard, there were still stupid customers in this world calling Blu-Rays DVD it' s
tha bunrt in to their heads.

DVD' s hand ass on plate.

DVDs still have plenty of life left in them both as a storage medium and as a movie format. Most people aren' t ready to switch to a high def format nor need more than 8 gigs of storage space on a disc for their own use. Those that do need more space have portable HDDs which have gotten very affordable especially in comparison to having to buy a Blu-Ray or HD-DVD drive along with the discs to use as a storage medium.

DVDs are really all people care about right now. Most couldn' t care less about the new formats. Upconvert DVD players (and tvs that do it on their own now) are making standard def DVDs look nearly as good as both of the new formats. Why spend all the extra money on the high def counter parts that look slightly better with a little extra bonus content when you can just use DVDs which work perfectly fine.

Since when was DVD on it' s last legs?

I don' t know I just talking trash.

quote:

ORIGINAL: mikayd2

So true dvd is kicking ass but its on its last leg.

Since when was DVD on it' s last legs?

Last I hard, there were still stupid customers in this world calling Blu-Rays DVD it' s
tha bunrt in to their heads.

DVD' s hand ass on plate.

DVD as a movie format has another 4 or 5 years left in it (industry supported). As a storage medium, another fifteen, easily. CD-ROM has been around since the mid eighties, and while movies, most games and large applications have long since jumped to DVD, the majority of commercial software is still being produced on CD-R.

Why spend all the extra money on the high def counter parts that look slightly better with a little extra bonus content when you can just use DVDs which work perfectly fine.

Because the average consumer can' t tell the difference between HD-Movies and their left arse-cheek. Half of what they' re experiencing are smooth tricks played by stores and media companies anyhow.

Ever gone into a Best-Buy and seen a couple ogling over the " amazing HD picture clarity" of a 1080p TV and a Blu-Ray player, only to turn the corner & see that the television' s displaying in R/F?

People are stupid.

Upconvert DVD players (and tvs that do it on their own now) are making standard def DVDs look nearly as good as both of the new formats.

Yeah right. I' ve seen upconverted DVD compared to Blu-ray on my HD screen. DVD' s can' t hold a candle campared to HD formats. Just because the pixels fit, that doesn' t mean it has more detail than it did before. Shit goes in, shit comes out.

I see what you' re saying about HD formats not taking off yet, that much is obvious. HD media won' t advance much faster than the adoption of HD TV' s. It will probably take about five to ten years before Blu-ray surpasses DVD.

Yeah right. I' ve seen upconverted DVD compared to Blu-ray on my HD screen. DVD' s can' t hold a candle campared to HD formats. Just because the pixels fit, that doesn' t mean it has more detail than it did before. Shit goes in, shit comes out.

People are stupid.

ORIGINAL: Agent Ghost

Yeah right. I' ve seen upconverted DVD compared to Blu-ray on my HD screen. DVD' s can' t hold a candle campared to HD formats. Just because the pixels fit, that doesn' t mean it has more detail than it did before. Shit goes in, shit comes out.

I didn' t say they were as good, I just pointed out it makes it look good. Have you seen a regular DVD player running on an HDTV? It' s horrible. An upconvert DVD player makes a huge difference. Again, not as good as HD-DVD or Blu-Ray but still great quality.