ABa mayby you doesn' t realise that each person who reviews each game at IGN is just a game with his own tatse.

They doesn' t ask themself,how would the majority of FPS gamers think about this?

They write what they liked or felt about the game,and thats how they should do it,thus you get to follow certain critics that yo ucan agree with.

For me Halo is a 9.6/10.

I can fully understand why you or others doesn' t agree with me,but you have to understand that a lot of people really loved Halo and halo2,thats why it got so good ratings and sold so extremly well.

I got friends who think FF7 is worth 6/10,and is fucking retarded,but thats their opinion,and they should accept that the critics doesn' t agree with them.

aba your a fuckin sony fanboy who doesnt know what a good game is, i really dont think you have the right to an opinion anymore.

i' m sure you' re right, like when you said there was a cow in the sky...

Abasoufiane mentioned reviews as a reply to mastachefbkws:

the media did not overrate it, i think ign gave it a 9 when it deserved like a 9.7 atleast,

Abasoufiane said:

IGN scored HALO a 9.7, yes mister a 9.7

Which is actually what mastachefbks thought it deserved.
mastachefbks said:

Jade empire wasnt overrated or hyped, and was a great game. Not too hard, not annoying, not extremely addicting.

He thinks Jade Empire wasn' t overrated but Abasoufiane says it was and motivates that by posting

IGN gave 9.9 for that game , i' m fucking crying now everytime i remember that , i was EXTREMLY dispointed, of course the game is all right but it is far from 9.9, what a fucking joke.. not only IGN but some other sites as well, yahoo a 10/10

Using a review is very motivated as the whole debate is about the game being OVERRATED or not.

Shenmue sucked. way overrated
shenmue 2 same as the fist

I hate you for that mastachefbks!!!!!!

GT series is way overrated and over hyped by sonyfanboys. its gotta be one of the crappiest racing games ever. if i wanted a racing game i would play a NFS or PGR game.

You' re comparing a simulation game (GT) to more arcade type games (NFS, PGR).
If you want to I could make a comparison between Super Smash Bros and Virtua Fighter but that' d only be the same thing.

How can one review be the proof about a game being overrated?

I seen a review in which FF7 got a 6/10.

That doesn' t mean it' s underrated game.

There is always gonna be a few who doesn' t care what others give,and that' s how it should be.

So that guy at IGN really loved the chinese culture mixing with a swkotor styled game.

So what?

He can' t give it a 9.9 then?

If he think it' s perfect,i can bet my ass that Aba hasn' t even played it.

Also Jeff gurstman at gamespot gaved tony hawk 2 10/10,why don' t i hear Aba complain about that?

Cause it came to ps2.

Cause it came to ps2.

why do you always try to point i' m a fanboy ??

i didn' t mention tony hawk because i didn' t know about that review + i don' t care about tony hawk taht' s why i didn' t check that review in the first pace ...

Also Jeff gurstman at gamespot gaved tony hawk 2 10/10,why don' t i hear Aba complain about that?

There was no Tony Hawk 2 on the PS2. There was Pro Skater 2 though but that was released on the Xbox as well.
Also, the game that got 10/10 was Pro Skater 3 which also was released on the Xbox. The Xbox reviewer did " only" give it 9.6 though.
Or did I miss the game you are refering to Quez?
How the hell can a skating game get a score that high? Judging by the screens the art direction and graphics alone are reasons enough NOT to give it 10.

Nah that was the one,i just forgot the name of it.

The pc version got 9/10.

Hwoever the point is,some reviewers does thing like this and it' s okay by me,then atleast i know which people i shouldn' t care about.

It was the same guy who trashed shenmue,ff7 and n3.

hey quez that' s the point of the thread , the moist overrated games or overhyped just to see if most of us agree on some games.