I' ve not replied to this thread the 3 or 4 times I' ve seen it reincarnated, so heres my shot.
Both.
Sometimes a particular type of game only comes to one platform in its purest form. For example BF2 on the PC.
The days of a PC being the primary platform of FPS and of consoles only having Lara Croft clones are long gone.
PC' s have stuggled with interface technology for games other than FPS for a long time. However you put it a PC keyboard will not have the responsiveness that a 360 pad has. Luckily these lines are now being blurred by being able to plug your 360 pad straight into a usb port. Thank christ.
Even still, its still an hour of tweaking settings and dead zone' s to get things just right. A console is bang it on, throw a controller at your mates et voila.. forced social interaction of a kind!
Consoles are definetly healthier from that perspective, they are open ended and inviting to new users and support widenening participation of new types of games and gamers. PC' s are more of an individual' s machine tailored via extreme cash eexpendature!
Ying & Yang if you will.
It' s also worth remembering that for a very long time before PC' s went 3d, they were pwned by consoles and lets not forget.. home computers!
Consoles are the arcade' s grandchildren. Consoles are now like the arcades used to be. Except rather than just being everywhere, they are with you everywhere.
My Alienware laptop will certainly never be " Mobile " that' s for sure - my girlfriend cant even pick it up! A DS or PSP simply aspires to gameplay at certain compromises technically. PC gamers don' t compromise!
I suppose it' s like that " wii' ing and ps3ing video " that was posted up.. expect the fat woman is the PC and the gaming consoles are the nubile blonde.. both satisfy different desires.